Paul Scarsella

Paul Scarsella began his career as an assistant Franklin County Prosecutor in 1997. Soon after, he joined the first gang prosecution unit developed in Ohio. After working as an assistant prosecutor in Franklin and Delaware counties, Paul joined the Attorney General’s Office, where he started the Special Prosecutions Unit in 2007. During his ten years in Special Prosecutions, Paul prosecuted some of the most high-profile murder cases throughout Ohio. Paul led the prosecution teams in the Ohio Craigslist Killing cases (State v Richard Beasley, State v Brogan Rafferty), the Inman family murder (State v William Inman Sr, State v. William Inman Jr), and other cold case homicides dating back to the 1970s. Paul left government service in 2018 and brought those 20 years of prosecution experience to the defense of those now charged with similar crimes. That experience as a prosecutor allows Paul to fully evaluate and best determine the investigative needs of a case. His experience has allowed him to develop relationships with investigators and experts necessary to assist in the defense of his clients.

Olivia Rancour

A proud graduate of Ohio University, Olivia earned her undergraduate degree in Political Science with Department Honors and minored in Psychology. She then studied at the University of Akron’s School of Law & College of Business, earning her Juris Doctor with a joint Master in Business Administration. Upon obtaining her JD/MBA, Olivia wasted no time returning to her hometown of Columbus to make her mark in the legal arena.

Guided by a deep-seated commitment to justice and a belief in the fundamental principle of the presumption of innocence, Olivia’s passion for protecting individuals’ rights in the face of criminal charges has been a driving force throughout her career.

Her empathy and understanding of clients’ challenges make her a trusted ally during the legal process. Olivia is known for her ability to connect with clients personally, providing not just legal guidance but emotional support during what can be a daunting experience.

Ever committed to staying at the forefront of legal developments, Olivia is an active Ohio State Bar Association member and regularly attends legal conferences and seminars to keep up with the latest legal strategies and insights.